Clause 73 - Manufactured payments: stock lending arrangements

Part of Finance Bill – in a Public Bill Committee am 3:15 pm ar 11 Mehefin 2013.

Danfonwch hysbysiad imi am ddadleuon fel hyn

Photo of David Gauke David Gauke The Exchequer Secretary 3:15, 11 Mehefin 2013

Clause 73 makes changes to block tax-avoidance schemes involving stock lending arrangements, as the hon. Lady points out. Those schemes claim to exploit a weakness in the current legislation; blocking them will lead to greater fairness by ensuring that everyone involved in stock lending pays their fair share of tax.

I will briefly set out some background to the clause. Manufactured payments arise as a normal part of the financial system, where a company lends shares or other securities to another company. If a dividend is paid on the shares when the shares are out on loan, the borrower of the shares is generally required to pay a manufactured payment representing the dividend to the stock lender. That payment will be taxed where it arises as part of a financial trade.

There are anti-avoidance provisions in the tax legislation to prevent companies and individuals avoiding this tax charge by paying the manufactured payments to someone  other than the lender, then receiving a payment from that other person in a non-taxable form, for example, a loan write-off within a group of companies.

The schemes blocked by the clause involve paying just part of the manufactured payment in a non-taxable form rather than all of it. It is claimed that that circumvents the legislation. While we do not accept that those schemes achieve the tax-avoidance effect that they claim, the clause will put it beyond doubt that the manufactured payment is taxable however it is made.

The changes made by clause 73 will ensure that the company that receives manufactured payments is taxed on them in whatever form they are paid. For example, if a company benefits by having an outstanding loan written off, that will lead to a tax charge, as they have received manufactured payment. Similar changes are being made to the equivalent income tax provisions.

The hon. Member for Newcastle upon Tyne North asked how many companies were involved in that avoidance and how much tax was lost. HMRC is aware of one company using the scheme. It was first identified in 2011, so it has been used over the past couple of years. Tax loss from the scheme was £50 million a year. It is important to take action promptly as the scheme could have been used by any company involved in financial trading, so there is a risk of that becoming more widely used. Hence, clause 73 would close down an avoidance scheme and bring certainty to companies and individuals involved in manufactured payments for genuine reasons.