Clause 23 - Loan relationships: debts becoming held by connected company

Part of Finance Bill – in a Public Bill Committee am 5:00 pm ar 12 Mehefin 2012.

Danfonwch hysbysiad imi am ddadleuon fel hyn

Photo of John Mann John Mann Llafur, Bassetlaw 5:00, 12 Mehefin 2012

Well, we will all await with interest the response to that intervention, myself included.

There are two good reasons to support the amendment. The hon. Member for Amber Valley, my would-be future neighbour, cited the most compelling one: Tony Blair, as a young MP in 1987, seeing democracy emerging before him, felt that it was appropriate to point out that retrospective legislation is a bad thing, and who are we to disagree with such an outstanding Prime Minister? I am virtually convinced for that reason alone.

The hon. Member for Amber Valley has had the courage to table the amendment. It strikes me that his proposal is sound and that the Government are unsound. Given that at least two Members present are on the  Treasury Committee, deliberated on the issue and reached consensus, I know that he is looking forward to at least two votes in support of his amendment: one from me, and a second from a Member on the Government Benches. It is only right that we members of the Treasury Committee show consistency in our wisdom in criticising the Bill. I suspect that the Government feel that the amendment is so well worded that they have to accept it. I look forward to hearing that.