asked the Secretary of State for War why the rates in hostels for the wives of serving soldiers are the same for all ranks; and if he is aware that it is unreasonable to expect a woman with three children, receiving £3 19s. 6d., who is expected to pay £3 4s. a week, to live on 15s. 6d. for all incidental expenses.

The rates charged are the same for all ranks because the accommodation and food provided is the same. Families of men on the lowest rates of pay are, however, safeguarded by a provision that after paying the requisite charges the remaining family income shall not be less than 25s. a week. The charge of £3 4s. a week for full board and lodging for a woman and three children includes service, fuel and light. I am, however, looking further into this. As regards the particular case referred to in the last part of the Question, I do not know whether or not the husband is making a reasonable allotment from his pay, but I am perfectly willing to have inquiries made into this aspect of the matter.

If the soldier were not making a reasonable allotment, what would then be the position with regard to the balance of money from the woman?

I am afraid that is beyond my power. The soldier is expected to make a reasonable allotment, and in the measure in which he does, obviously the woman and her family are better off.

Does not the right hon. Gentleman's answer tend to show that the present pay rates are inadequate?