asked the Minister of Food how much of the saving of 4,000 tons of flour a week for the 30 weeks ended 30th August, 1947, compared with the 30 weeks immediately before bread rationing, is accounted for by the reduction of deliveries for industrial and export purposes respectively; and if he will state the net saving attributed to the use of bread rationing coupons during the latter period as compared with the former.

The answer to the first part of the Question is, "None, Sir." Of the reduction of 4,000 tons per week in deliveries from mills in the period referred to, it is estimated that about 3,000 tons per week can be attributed to the operation of the rationing scheme.

In view of the fact that the saving is now so tiny, could the Minister say how long her right hon. Friend needs to prolong this farce?

I do not agree with the hon. Member—it is quite useful—in view of the fact that the hon. Member has taken a period when there was a shortage of potatoes, and, therefore, a heavy call on bread.

It is only 3 per cent.